For industrial applications, the lighting designer must consider a variety of
factors including user needs and preferences, safety regulations, maintenance
requirements and energy consumption.
Analysis of the Industrial Space
One important aspect of design
is a detailed analysis of the interior environment of the industrial space.
Functional elements that impact lighting design and effect the overall light
delivered to the task include ceiling height, room surface finishes, windows,
skylights or other fenestrations, and the geometry of the space. Environmental
conditions, including dust and dirt, moisture, wet locations, hose-down areas,
insects, temperature extremes, vibration and incidental abuse have a significant
effect on the selection of the proper luminaire. Food processing areas, for
example, sometimes require special options for lighting fixtures.
Exterior spaces also require evaluation. Lighting can enhance the
architectural features of a building at night and also provide safety and
security as it directs people to entrances. General exterior considerations
include the type and color of exterior building materials, type and location of
plants used in the landscape, and the placement of exterior lighting so it does
not interfere with driveways or produce glare.
Lighting renovations should consider the same design criteria as new
construction, as well as issues of existing wiring, changes in task locations,
and removal of hazardous wastes.
Evaluation of Psychological
Aspects
Employee attitude can have a dramatic impact on productivity. While the
lighting designer cannot address all related issues, effective lighting design
can have a positive impact. Proper lighting can increase employee comfort with
the effective use of colors, contrast, and luminance. Control of glare can
reduce visual fatigue.
Requirements for
Flexibility in Lighting
In
today’s dynamic environment, changes in the workplace often require general
renovations. If the location of assembly lines or storage racks changes, the
lighting must be re-evaluated. In applications where task locations change
frequently, the use of flexible wiring systems may offer significant advantages.
Initial installation time will be reduced, and relocating luminaires in the
future becomes much easier and more cost-effective.
Task requirements may also change throughout the day. Manufacturing
activities may be conducted during one shift, maintenance of equipment performed
during another shift, and security may be necessary during the non-productive
periods. Lighting needs will vary, therefore automatic on/off switching
and or dimming controls may be beneficial.
Safety Requirements
Light levels must be sufficient to minimize on-the-job injuries which occur
more frequently in industrial settings. Of particular interest is the
stroboscopic effect, a condition in which rotating machinery appears to stand
still because it operates at the same frequency (60 cycles per second) as
electric current. Stroboscopic effect can be eliminated with fluorescent
electronic ballasts, which operate at higher frequencies – 20,000 cycles per
second and higher – or by connecting adjacent fixtures to different phases of
three-phase electrical distribution systems. In addition, well designed lighting
can also minimize damage to machinery and inventory which reduces overall costs
and may lower insurance rates.
Lighting must also ensure a safe environment during an emergency. In the
event of a fire or power outage, emergency lighting and exit signs must enable
occupants to identify a clear path of egress, even through smoke.
Installation and Maintenance
Requirements
Installation and maintenance requirements can be important
considerations when choosing industrial lighting system. In many cases,
industrial luminaires are mounted at high elevations, directly over machinery,
or in locations where special equipment is required to access the luminaire.
Choose components that minimize labor requirements such as long life lamps and
quick-connect modular wiring. With modular wiring, fixture installation is
accomplished in a fraction of the time it takes for conventional hardwiring, and
fixture relocation is fast and easy.
Building and Electrical Codes
Many states, provinces and
regions have enacted energy code for local building construction. Also, as a
result of the Energy Policy Act 1992 (EPACT), all states are required to meet
minimum energy requirements as specified in the ASHRAE
/ IESNA Standard 90.1 1999 code. Standard 90.1 establishes
watts-per-square-foot criteria for various types of applications. Among other
factors to be considered are the requirements of the Americans with Disabilities
Act which provides guidelines and specifications for barrier-free environments.
Energy Requirements
Lighting is a primary energy component for industrial applications. Careful
consideration of the lighting energy-use can have a substantial impact on
operating costs. Design criteria should evaluate the local energy rate, lighting
usage requirements throughout the day, and the availability of energy saving
technologies. Control systems such as motion sensors, daylighting sensors, time
of day controls and energy management systems can further reduce energy
consumption.
To help designers evaluate the energy efficiency of luminaires, a metric
called Luminaire Efficacy Rating (LER) is used. This metric describes the
luminaire’s delivered light output compared to the energy input – or lumens
per watt. The National Electrical
Manufacturer’s Association has developed guidelines for LER values for
industrial fluorescent and high-intensity discharge luminaires1.
The US Environmental Protection Agency
(EPA) promotes two programs that emphasize energy efficient lighting systems.
Green Lights is a voluntary pollution prevention program. By joining Green
Lights, partners agree to install energy efficient lighting where profitable as
long as lighting quality is maintained or improved. Lithonia actively
participates in this program as a Green Lights Ally.
The ENER Buildings program
is another voluntary energy-efficiency program. It focuses on overall load
reductions for building systems including lighting, heating, ventilation,
air-conditioning, motors, and fans. Partners can expect to reduce total building
energy consumption by 30% on average. Internal rates of return (IRR) range from
17% to 50%. Lithonia Lighting is proud to have received the Energy Star Exit
Sign Partner of the Year award in 1998 and 1999 for outstanding product and
services for Exit Lighting.
Cost Considerations
The overall cost of the lighting system depends on a number of variables:
the initial cost to purchase and install the system, the costs associated with
operation and maintenance, and the energy required to operate the lighting.
Energy is the most significant overall cost for lighting. Small incremental
costs in purchasing energy-saving components are paid back quickly with the
operating savings. Premium materials may increase initial capital costs as well,
but offer such advantages as superior color rendition, better maintenance, and
lower operating costs.
It is also important to consider the financial benefits that result from high
quality lighting: improved productivity, lower rejection rates, better quality
control, and increased customer satisfaction. According to the National Lighting
Bureau2, high quality lighting has been shown to
reduce rejection rates by 25 percent or more.
1.National Electrical Manufacturers Association
Standard Publication No. LE5 – 1993, "Procedure for Determining Luminaire
Efficacy Ratings for Fluorescent Luminaires" and Publication No. LE5B –
1998 "Procedure for Determining Luminaire Efficacy Ratings for High
Intensity Discharge Industrial Luminaires" (publication pending)
2.National Lighting Bureau, "The NLB Guide to
Industrial Lighting", 1992